Britax car seat

Recommended car seats, by Consumer Reports

“Of all things you’ll buy for your child, a good car seat is one of the most important,” says Consumer Reports. “You’ll need a car seat from the moment you take baby home from the hospital until he or she grows up enough to fit into adult seat belts, typically around the age of 8 or later.”

Car seats can be divided in five categories:

Infant. “This provides the best fit for newborns and smaller babies, and can be used for children from 4 lbs. to 40, depending on the model.”

Convertible. “This is likely the next step after outgrowing an infant seat, to be purchased no later than a child’s first birthday.”

Booster. “When your child outgrows the weight and height limit for a forward-facing seat’s harness, it’s time for a booster that uses a car’s own seat belt.”

All-in-one. “They provide great value by taking a child from birth to booster. They’re a tempting money-saver, but our tests have found that by trying to do too much they don’t do any single task all that well.”

Toddler booster. “They are a less expensive alternative to convertible seats (if your child meets the forward-facing age and weight requirements), and offer a safe option for an older child not yet ready for a booster or a transition seat.”

Here is the Consumer Reports’ selection of recommended car seats. The maximum overall score is 100, and “Best Buy” models offer more value.


Infant car seat

Chicco KeyFit

Overall score: 86
“Best Buy”

Chicco KeyFit 30

Overall score: 84

GB Asana 35 DLX

Overall score: 82

Combi Shuttle

Overall score: 77

Cybex Aton Q

Overall score: 73

Cybex Aton 2

Overall score: 73

Maxi-Cosi Mico AP

Overall score: 73

UPPAbaby Mesa

Overall score: 72

Safety 1st onBoard35

Overall score: 70
“Best Buy”

Back to top


Convertible car seat

Chicco NextFit

Overall score: 82

Evenflo SureRide

Overall score: 74
“Best Buy”

Evenflo Titan 65

Overall score: 74

Cosco Scenera NEXT

Overall score: 73
“Best Buy”

Graco Contender 65

Overall score: 72
“Best Buy”

Graco Size4Me 65

Overall score: 71

Graco Head Wise 65

Overall score: 71

Graco My Ride 65

Overall score: 70
“Best Buy”

Back to top


Booster seat

Highback-to-backless boosters

Evenflo Big Kid Amp Highback

Overall score: 72
“Best Buy”

Evenflo Big Kid Sport

Overall score: 72
“Best Buy”

Evenflo Big Kid DLX

Overall score: 69

Evenflo Big Kid LX

Overall score: 69

Highback boosters

Cybex Solution X-Fix Plus

Overall score: 65
“Best Buy”

Backless boosters

Harmony Youth Booster Seat

Overall score: 68
“Best Buy”

Back to top


All-in-one car seat

Graco Milestone

Overall score: 79
“Best Buy”

Graco 4Ever

Overall score: 75

Evenflo Symphony (With SureLATCH)

Overall score: 72
“Best Buy”

Back to top


Toddler booster seat

Greater than 40 lb. harness capacity toddler booster seats

Graco Nautilus 3-in-1

Overall score: 75
“Best Buy”

Evenflo SecureKid DLX (400)

Overall score: 64
“Best Buy”

40 lb. harness capacity toddler booster seats

Cosco Highback Booster

Overall score: 69
“Best Buy”

Back to top


Consumer Reports is an American magazine published monthly since 1936. It features reviews and comparisons of consumer products and services based on reporting and results from its in-house testing laboratory and survey research centre. The magazine accepts no advertising, pays for all the products it tests, and, as a not-for-profit organisation, has no shareholders. It also publishes cleaning and general buying guides. (Wikipedia.)

Source: Consumer Reports
Last checked on: 27 November 2017
Image: